A Triumphant Romp in the "Woods"


          The cast of the new Broadway revival of Into the Woods. Photo by Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman.

The power of the late composer-lyricist Stephen Sondheim became greater after his sudden death at age 91 in November. That power was evidenced recently in Steven Spielberg’s excellent remake of West Side Story (currently streaming on HBO Max and Disney Plus) as well as the splendid, revolutionary Tony-winning revival of Company (which will be closed on Broadway July 31st.) Now, Sondheim’s spirit lifts again in the brilliant revival of Into the Woods, currently playing a limited engagement at the St. James Theatre until August 21st. This production is fresh from its smash-hit, sold-out run earlier this spring as part of NY City Center’s Encores series. Some of its cast members, such as Sara Bareilles and Gavin Creel, have retained their roles for the downtown run of the show.

This musical is a fairy tale, and it interweaves four classic fables (Cinderella, Rapunzel, Jack and the Beanstalk, Little Red Riding Hood) with an original story (The Baker and his wife) and mixes them together into a thrilling journey that’s exciting, spellbinding and grabs you in the heart and mind. In it, the Baker (understudy Jason Forbach) and his wife (Bareilles) are wishing for a child, as is Cinderella (Phillipa Soo), who wants to go to the ball, and Jack (fill-in Alex Joseph Grayson), who wants his cow Milky White (puppeteered by Kennedy Kanagawa) to make milk. Soon, the Witch (Patina Miller), who has a long history with the Baker’s family, makes a deal with the Baker to make his dream of being a father come true. She requests the Baker to get Little Red Riding Hood’s cape, Jack’s cow, a piece of Rapunzel’s hair, and Cinderella’s glass slipper within three days so that the wish can come true.

The Baker’s Wife teams up with her husband for these various tasks. Along the way, the journey provides us with moments of joy and fantasy, such as two princes (Gavin Creel and Joshua Henry) lamenting about their true loves, Jack discovering magic beans that create a beanstalk that leads into encountering some “giants in the sky,” and Little Red Riding Hood (understudy Delphi Borich) running into a big, bad wolf (Creel again). The main story ends delightfully in Act One, but in Act Two, it shows that life in a fairy-tale isn’t as happily ever after as anyone hoped.

A big bouquet of flowers must be sent to director Lear DeBessonet for transferring this wondrous work from City Center to the St. James, where it deserves to have an open-ended run. James Lapine’s book is still intact after 35 years, and the soaring score by Sondheim is still timeless as it’s performed by a great, onstage 15-person orchestra composed by Rob Berman and well-orchestrated by Sondheim collaborator Jonathan Tunick. As it shows on the stage, it’s an intimate production. David Rockwell has created a set that showcases the cast and orchestra to significant effect without overwhelming it with big set pieces. Tyler Micoleau’s lighting makes this show light up brightly, as does Andrea Hood’s colorful costumes.

The cast here is fantastic. Among the standouts are Bareilles, Creel in his dual roles, Miller, and in their understudy roles, Borich, Grayson, and Forbach. A round of applause must go to The Telsey Office for casting one of the best and most diverse casts in New York City right now.

The last 25 minutes felt bittersweet for me because the musical’s final three songs (“No More,” “No One is Alone,” and “Children Will Listen”) convey the feelings that many have felt in these past three years of changing and challenging times in this country. These moments assure us that Into the Woods is a show for our times.

Whatever you’re doing this summer, please add this nothing short of perfect show to your must-see list and get your tickets now. The show’s time here on Broadway may be limited for now, but I wish it would stay here hopefully for a much-deserved long run.

Into the Woods is currently playing at the St. James Theatre on 246 West 44th Street (between Broadway and 8th Avenue) for a limited engagement until August 21st. For tickets, go to seatgeek.com.

Note: Cheyenne Jackson will be filling in for Creel's roles from July 24th thru August 2nd.

Comments